Adhyaropa Darsana Verse 8
This is terrible and empty
like a phantom city;
even as such, the whole
is made as a wonder by the
Terrible and empty of
Like a city infernal,
Even as such a marvel
Did the Lord make the whole
you should have been there! On a classic Oregon stormy night, we had another
community leap into the depths of the verse, covering a wide range of
territory. I am totally daunted to try and reproduce a significant amount of
it. Wish me luck!
opened with the thought that the core of this commentary is asking, what is it
we are conscious of and how are we conscious of it? In addressing this we are
aiming for a lucid understanding of our overarching Self. She pointed out that
the verse’s first word—this—refers back to the previous verse, where it is said
that substantiation by name and form, grounded in ignorance, is the empty
content we project as our world. Here again it is underlined as terrible, in
case we’ve missed the point. It’s okay if this bothers you. In fact, if it
doesn’t bother you, you aren’t likely to seek truth, as the effort to forge a
more solid basis of understanding is often called. Presumably everyone along on
this group study would prefer to reduce their ignorance and is willing to make
at least a modicum of effort to put together an improved version of themselves.
lot of the commentary seems to refer more to the next verse, being a survey of
different views of how the world has evolved. Nitya liked to lead his students
on extended meditations like this. But there are some very relevant ideas
sprinkled throughout it. Fortunately, Nitya provides a “pull quote” that
expresses the gist of not only the verse but the whole endeavor of Darsanamala
in two short sentences:
The world we think to be real has
in fact very little objective reality. It is padded out in all directions with
half-baked conceptual notions and hidebound prejudices.
gurus assure us that this is not a fixed situation that we are helpless to deal
with, although we are bound to remain limited to some degree. Nonetheless we
have plenty of control over skinning the hide off our prejudices and baking our
ideas more fully. Sure, a devious part of us resists enlightenment with all its
wiles, but if we are dedicated to overcoming our own resistance we can make
plenty of meaningful progress. To add to the incentive, Nitya adds another key
concept, impeccably stated:
What has been experienced by us
in the past reasserts itself in the present in every situation, appearing as a
frightening and ghostlike presence which haunts us in our transactions with the
As we have learned, usually these pernicious influences are
invisible, just like ghosts. We have to infer them from their effects, and this
requires self-observation and welcoming the opinions of others. It’s not always
easy, but the results are often quite satisfying. We did some wonderful work
together last night.
thing that finally occurred to me at long last is an implication of the second
half of the verse. Not only our personal substantiation, but the world too is
made from the beginning as a phantom
city, empty of real content. It is wonderful and marvelous, as well as terrible
and empty. This means that the solution to life’s problems is not to be found
in some ultimate transactional answer. It isn’t that we can finally “get it
right” and after that everything is okay. There is no perfect state within the
transactional. We cannot have a life free of difficulties. The world is
inevitably dual, and will always have good and bad aspects generating
dissonance. We can refine our understanding, and spread kindness and
consideration wherever we go, but the hope that we will eventually achieve an
earthly paradise is a vain one. The only resolution comes from reacquainting
ourselves with the source, rather than trying to resolve the chaos. The chaos
is not going away no matter what we do.
this, we appear to be doomed to keep trying to fix everything with the perfect
program. Narayana Guru is hinting that this is a fool’s errand. Instead we can
accept the frailty of every system and every human attempt to live well, making
us more tolerant and compassionate even as we staunchly resist becoming bogged
down in prejudiced and conditioned thinking. It’s actually a profound idea, if
we take the time to assess how our actions are motivated by the attempt to get
the right answer, instead of relating our partial vision with a universal basis
that infuses everything. The invitation here is to a major change of
most easily practical aspect of our study is touched on by another of Nitya’s
clearly stated ideas:
Two threatening aspects of life
are our present ruminations on past experiences, which arouse regret and
remorse, and the fear which arises when we contemplate the uncertainty of the
future. Remorse related to the past and anxiety related to the future—so much
of these overlap into the present that the world begins to look like the Inferno
for a great many people.
is of course a very familiar idea, and yet it bears revisiting. Jan affirmed
that she is going through a difficult time of transition, and this philosophy
has helped her to keep heart and remain optimistic. She has a lot of
uncertainty in her life right now. She keeps trying to be present instead of
looking ahead too much, and when she manages this she knows she is more in
touch with her loving feelings and all that is great with the world. It’s not
that there aren’t serious challenges, but she is trying not to add her fears of
what might go wrong. She well knows that the anxiety this generates undermines
her ability to face what she has to deal with in a competent manner.
changes always brings up worries about the unknown future, and it is anything
but easy to reassure ourselves that it is going to be okay. You would think
that a lifetime of more or less successful outcomes would be enough to give us
confidence, but that isn’t how our brains work, apparently. Remember how Atmo
verse 66 is Narayana Guru’s assertion of this truth, beginning: “Food and all
such always come again as a matter of course.” Still, when we’re hungry we
worry. We need reassurance, in addition to food. Food can stand for all items
of need, of course.
point is not to abstain from having goals, but to move toward our goals
uncluttered with expectations and worries. Nitya was a great example of how
this works. He often had visions, directions, programs, but he didn’t draw up
specific plans. He intuited a need or a good idea, and left it to the universe
to implement it. He thought about it and gave himself to it, but had faith that
it would come about if it was worthwhile. Many things fell together under his
auspices. It often looked like a kind of everyday magic was springing up
everywhere around him.
provides another example of how we do this. Like Jan she is in transition and
is looking for a new house to buy. She has the vision that this is where she is
going, and she makes the necessary efforts to bring it about, which are quite
demanding, especially right now in Portland. She strives to keep a calm and
equal-minded attitude while she is going about the search process, looking for
the perfect place to settle down again. She knows that anxiety about the
outcome will only cloud her peace of mind and make meeting the challenge harder
than it already is. She also has to expand the rigid expectations she naturally
has based on her previous (exceptional!) living situations, so that she can appreciate
the possibilities of places that are superficially different from what she is
used to. She admits that some days she is better at remaining neutral than
others. In any case, there is a mutual participation between the possibilities
afforded by the environment and her own efforts to match up with them. It gives
her the chance to weed out extraneous modes of thought.
talked about how people often argue that there are so many awful things going
on in the world, how can anyone keep their equanimity? Shouldn’t they be upset?
The solution isn’t to pretend that problems don’t exist so you can live in a
vacuum, but to be fully present in every situation. That is the optimal
contribution; worrying about distant “rumors of wars” doesn’t accomplish anything
admitted he sometimes feels guilty that with all the chaos in the world he can
remain dispassionate and removed. Yet it is still so easy to get rattled. Some
little thing happens—many of us have had water leaks in our houses this week,
for instance—and you feel put upon by fate. Somehow we have to deal with the
“leaks” and console ourselves that they are as much a part of reality as the
also felt that the meditation Nitya recounted was one he could relate to:
Once Narayana Guru asked a disciple, who later became Nataraja
meditate upon the room in which he sat as though nothing existed outside of it.
He wanted his disciple to practice living entirely in the present moment and
Paul could feature going into a room and subtracting
everything from his mind beyond immediate perception. It would feel good. Give
the gift of presence. I agreed that we should do something like this
occasionally, possibly daily. There is a value in pulsating between small and local
and broad and general. Each feeds and counterbalances the other. Often we bring
our general beliefs in to the small room with us. The trick is to check them at
elaborates this key idea beautifully:
The world presented to us as
individuals is not the entire universe. It is a very limited environment of a
relatively few square miles in area, and which belongs entirely to the present
moment. We can perhaps give it a time-span of a few hours. The problems arising
from it are likely to be few and simple, but we complicate matters which should
only arise from, and relate to, our individual environment, by hooking on to
them the structuring of a vast and complex world. The world with which we
complicate our responses to sensory input is the conditioning passed on to us
from generation after generation.
summed up that it all boiled down to a matter of being present. The way we
react to things is like the phantom city, and we need to know we are the Self
and not the phantom. Nitya’s conclusion brings this home poignantly:
here and now is always simple. It is a great wonder that we insist on
complicating it, thereby introducing an element of dread, by linking it with a
dead yesterday and an unknown tomorrow. This we do at the expense of our
enjoyment of the present, which could otherwise be a loving and meaningful
experience of the Self.
reminded Susan of something she once heard from a therapist, that she should be
planetary instead of orbiting other people’s planets. All our half-baked
notions keep us on the periphery, focused on family members and difficult
situations, instead of sinking into ourselves. If we are planetary, we actually
have more effect on others around us. In our orbiting as untethered asteroids
we mean to be effective, but we don’t have enough gravity to accomplish very
much. We can all observe how Susan is beginning to really put this advice into
practice, and it’s heartening to see.
me, this verse isn’t just suggesting an occasional technique to be put into
practice during meditation. Everything we encounter affords us the opportunity
to center ourselves in the present. Nitya’s point about “half-baked conceptual
notions” speaks to this. Normally we react before we understand the full story.
We should not be content with this! On a large scale, the reason black ops work
so well is that nations react quickly to the provocation, and don’t concern
themselves with the real culprits. It makes impressive political propaganda,
and a lot of mayhem. We also do this in our relationships. Our first response
is often prejudiced and based on very limited information (which could be
called ignorance). If we allow for more information, we will almost certainly
change our tune. Unfortunately, humans are prone to do what nations do: react
quickly and then stand by the faulty position we’ve taken, deflecting all
attempts to correct the record.
said that thanks to her years in the class she had changed her way of thinking.
She used to always bring in her opinions into every discussion but now she is
comfortable leaving them. Where she reacted immediately to name and form, now
she sees that as her prejudice, and rethinks her position. It’s a very big
change for the better. Moni has always been kind and considerate, but that was
often at her own expense. It was forced to some degree, and sacrificial. Now it
is more natural, because she doesn’t have to hold onto her opinions so tightly.
often taught how for anything to be actualized, the potential has to already
exist in the Absolute ground. It is not empty. It looks empty, but it is filled
with potentials. We are the agents to actualize those potentials. Jan talked
about how that feels when you are at a crossroads, how you sense the
possibilities yet remain uncertain of your best choice. Knowing that you will
create a different reality depending on which way you go forces you to
concentrate intensely on your decision. It can even seem overwhelming.
of Robert Frost’s most famous poems, The Road Not Taken, captures the delicious
dilemma of not knowing which way to choose. (You can read it here, along with a
fairly interesting article deconstructing its popularity as, in fact, his most famous poem, and possibly the most
famous poem in the English language: http://www.theparisreview.org/blog/2015/09/11/the-most-misread-poem-in-america/).
I’ll include Nitya’s writing about the actualization of potentials in Part II.
there was so much more… I give up. One last idea I can share is something Deb
brought up. She was rather baffled by this part of the commentary:
Spirit before the creation of the world is depicted as the infant Krishna,
reclining on a fig leaf which floats on water, while sucking the big toe of his
right foot. There is also a famous sculpture by Rodin of a child feeling with
one finger a thorn stuck in the sole of his left foot. In all such ideograms we
have the idea of an existence prior to its manifestation.
This turned into a great example of brainstorming, as the
class came up with a number of insights. First, one image depicts pain and the
other pleasure. There is definitely a sense of meeting a new stimulus, of
exploring something, and perhaps of trying to figure out what to do. Nancy hit
the nail on the head: these images portray the junction between existence and
experiencing that existence. It is experienced by our interaction with it.
of the Rodin sculpture, Deb recalled an amusing incident from when our daughter
Harmony was about 2 years old. We were taking a walk in the Arizona desert,
actually on a manicured golf course, in the evening when nobody was around.
Harmony started saying, “Happening, happening.” We didn’t think anything of it
at first. To us, a happening was a cool event, a gathering of happy souls. Like
our family walk was a happening. But Harmony kept saying it, and became more
insistent: “Happening!” Suddenly I realized she was trying to say something
urgent with her limited vocabulary. After studying her for a while I looked at
her sandal-clad feet, and there was a three-inch long thorn stuck in her heel.
It was a very painful happening indeed! I suppose it also illustrates how our
conditioning kept us adults from getting the message right away, though we did
catch on eventually. And not too much blood was spilled.
class shared several examples of how our ignorance interferes with our
enjoyment and full participation in life. Perhaps you can think of your own examples
in the security of your own home. It’s always a relief to cast off those
As the visible world is like an infernal
city, empty of content (sunya) and
terrible (bhayamkaram) so in the most
wonderful manner, the visible and invisible aspects referring to all possible
worlds were created by the Lord.
Because the Lord is
all-powerful and capable of accomplishing anything, He was able to create
something which had no basis in reality, but still could be seen as a wonderful
appearance, because it is at once empty of content and terrible, though
describable as a marvel (adbhuta).
The term vibhuh employed in the verses refers to
omnipotence, and everlasting eternity of the Lord. (vi, before; and bhuh,
what exists; because it existed before, it is called vibhuh).
are some relevant thoughts from Nitya’s Psychodynamics
What is potentially not present in the cause cannot manifest
in the effect. Conversely, anything manifested as an effect is indicative of a
latent cause, a hidden seed. Here the limitation arises from a pulsation within
manifestation, expanding from a cause to an enlarged field of effect, and, in
the same manner, centripetally turning inward to epitomize the entire effect
into a causal factor. This process, which is going on interminably, is
happening in the unknown and in the unconscious. Therefore the entire
perspective of it is not available either to perceptual observation or to
conceptual comprehension. Here also, a limitation is set which has for its
frame of reference the time-space continuum and the intrinsic laws that govern
the origin, expansion, reduction and dissolution of mass. Omniscience in this
case is when the process in the unconscious has been maximally interpreted to
the conscious mind. When one cannot go farther into the niche of the
unconscious, the omniscience of causal consciousness reaches its insurmountable
The phenomenality of creation is a cyclic process, very much
like the spurting of water in a fountain, which remains visible in the process
of rising and falling, and then becomes one with the water of the reservoir,
only to be thrown up again in the next moment. Life on earth is also cyclic.
The process of obtaining a body, the use of it for carrying out whatever action
is appropriate, and finally disintegrating, to be transformed again into the
instrument of another living being, is just like the water circulating through
a fountain or a smith casting the same metal again and again into new forms.
In such processes, the water or metal and so on are not
enriched by the specific transformation they have undergone. But life is not
like that. Each embodiment enriches it with the registry of various experiences.
The cumulative effect of undergoing such experiences becomes embedded in the
genetic stream, the selective mold through which evolution is sustaining the
biologic principle of earth, which thus has in it a record of ceaseless
knew Jean would read the article on the Frost poem, and she sent a very helpful
I'll take the bait; it's a nice diversion. Here's a
little more history about "Road Not Taken." (Wikipedia)
Frost spent the years 1912 to 1915 in England, where
among his acquaintances was the writer Edward Thomas.
Thomas and Frost became close friends and took many walks together. After Frost
returned to New Hampshire in 1915, he sent Thomas an advance copy of "The
Road Not Taken." The
poem was intended by Frost as a gentle mocking of indecision, particularly the
indecision that Thomas had shown on their many walks together. Frost later
expressed chagrin that most audiences took the poem more seriously than he had
intended; in particular, Thomas took it seriously and personally, and it may
have been the last straw in Thomas' decision to enlist in World War I. Thomas
was killed two years later in the Battle of Arras.
It's neither here nor there, but it struck me suddenly that
the young Robert Frost (1874-1963) sure resembles the young Joe Hill
But the point is well taken (from the article you
suggested), that we always grapple with self-deception when constructing the
story of our own lives.
Psychodynamics of Pranava elaborates
on a section of the Patanjali Yoga Sutras, which we studied together a while
back. This is related to Sutra 1:30, and is essentially the same as what Nancy
used in the book, Living the Science of
Harmonious Union. I reprint it here because it’s so relevant to the
challenge of making good decisions and Frost’s poetic take on it, and it’s an
instance of Nitya’s great driving analogy of pressing down the brake and the
accelerator at the same time:
To arrive at a certain goal, even if you have the best mode
of transportation, if you have no mind to get up and drive your vehicle, you
will be sitting lost in boredom. As years go by, we see more and more people
who are exposed to mental depression. They know they have to get up and act,
but they cannot even make up their minds to hold a pen. This is the dysfunction
that comes from the mental side, called styana,
The body and mind can both get in each other’s way. The mind
is willing to go but the body sits there like a heavy load, or the body is
ready to move yet the mind is apprehensive about allowing the body to function.
The result is like the driver of a car who puts his feet firmly on the
accelerator and the brake at the same time—a lot of commotion goes on inside
but nothing happens. Such a person is aware of the dreadful waste of his time,
and that itself causes a drain of energy. Consequently, his energy cannot be
channelized in any direction. One of the greatest tragedies in human life is
that many hours are wasted each day because of this kind of inability to take a
decision. This is called samsaya,
When a machine is operating only at a throbbing level and
not put into gear, it becomes overheated. It is the same with our body-mind
machine. Sitting in one room and endlessly ruminating causes grievous distress
to one’s nervous system, and this causes many people to exaggerate. They become
nervous, irritable, and unable to cope with anyone or anything. Such a
delirious state is named pramada, exaggeration.
An exaggerating mind spends too much energy in a short time
and the body and mind feel exhausted. Nature’s way to prevent further
deterioration is to take away incentives to act, making the body and mind lazy.
This is alasya.