Asatya Darsana verse 9
the mature mind of the old the world appears
the Self as a forest in the sky,
as the unreal form of a puppet
otherwise to a child.
Nataraja Guru’s translation:
To the mature mind this
Looms like a sky-forest in
Even as an unreal
To a child (would
the deconstructive process of Darsanamala proceeds apace, the Asatya Darsana
builds to an unsettling implication, which drew us in to a fascinating exploration.
Because of the drastic nature of the subject, Nitya reminds us at the end of
where this is headed. Without his reassurance we might well lose our equipoise.
It’s high time to dispense with some of our cherished illusions, which are not
what we expect them to be.
Bill noted, the verse reveals a process of development. Innocent children
accept everything they perceive as real, even as they project their own
provisional and faulty interpretations onto the world around them. As Nitya
puts it, “The child does not draw a line between fact and fiction.” Meaning the
child’s fictions are taken as factual. We may still remember how we once imbued
a doll or puppet with an incontrovertible reality, and we could interact with
them just as we did our friends and family. Even better, often enough, as we
single-handedly supplied both sides of the dialogue.
maturation process Bill referred to is the gradual realization of the falseness
of certain elements, culminating in a stage late in life or at least advanced
maturity where, as with Vedanta, we perceive a measure of unreality in
everything manifest. Nitya describes how this fits with the verse:
As the child grows he will
discover that there is a deceptive element in his experiences which is capable
of thwarting his hopes and bringing them to dissatisfaction or frustration.
When other similar occasions arise in life, the growing child becomes wary of
so readily accepting things. Skepticism grows; truth and falsehood are
thereafter sorted out with increasing precision. When the child grows into a
mature youth, the critical acumen is applied to everything. Transactions become
rigid. Definitive criteria are employed to safeguard the verity of facts…. In
this stage of life the mind of a person is at the extreme opposite pole of the
child’s visualization. All transactions of life are once again treated as
make-believe, though of a reverse order.
Science and philosophy have progressed to the point where
even ‘facts’ and ‘definitive criteria’ are revealed to be provisional and
uncertain. The gurus suggest that only by aligning our psyche with a
theoretical absolute principle known as the Self can we avoid the loneliness
and desolation of old (or any) age. But that comes much later in the study.
First we have to rid ourselves of the false props we employ to inject meaning
into empty illusions. In a way we are still lending credence to a world of our
over-simplified imagination. Being dependent on the external ratification of
our existence—which is far and away the norm—we may surrender to despair as
everything we hold dear falls away. If our world is reduced to nothing but a
projected forest floating in midair like a mirage, we may well abandon hope. In
many respects, Darsanamala is Narayana Guru’s antidote to such despair. It is a
medicine that may be hard to swallow initially, but as Nataraja Guru famously
said, “A bad disease needs a drastic remedy.” (Gita 121) The remedy includes
facing our dilemma squarely, after a lifetime of avoidance, and this is
anything but easy.
makes it sound simple enough, if we are paying attention. Nitya explains: “According
to Shankara, an illusion disproves itself by becoming ineffective in showing
the intrinsic qualities or potential reactions of factual things or events.”
This is echoed by author Philip K. Dick’s definition: “Reality is that which,
when you stop believing in it, doesn’t go away.” But when do you stop believing
in it? Only when it fails you. In the meantime we are masters at prolonging our
illusions. Deb said that illusion proves itself by its insufficiency, by the
failed expectations that lie in its wake. Yet wouldn’t it be nice to change
course in advance of such a disaster?
hard part is bringing a balanced skepticism to bear on our cherished fantasies.
Moreover, we have to stay alert to not befuddle our thinking. Although the word
‘contrariwise’ has a long history, I can’t help but wonder if Nataraja Guru used
the word in his translation with Tweedledee (from Lewis Carroll’s Through the Looking-Glass) in mind:
Tweedledee, “if it was so, it might be; and if it were so, it would be; but as
it isn’t, it ain’t. That's logic.”
Pretty confusing logic at that! Yet if it’s convoluted
enough, it becomes plausible if we aren’t careful.
along the age continuum, Nitya turns his focus from young children to young
adults, with their own version of puppets:
A young person has to face a
complex world of emotional fantasies, generated by the instincts of sex or
self-preservation. Sexual fantasies make the mind romantic, and it attributes
to the loved one many imaginary qualities. In this case also, the principle of
efficiency acts as a reliable criterion to test the factuality of things
believed to be true. When lovers begin getting into each other’s need to
respond to their several demands, transactions reveal the inefficaciousness of
their assumptions. As a result, disillusionment comes.
When his puppets no longer behave like rag dolls and instead
stand up for their own needs and feelings, the puppeteer is sure to be
frustrated and dismayed. He may generate religious or social strictures to
force the puppets to behave as he wants. We live in a time when many former
puppets gallantly refuse to be shrunk to servile status, and demand their right
to independence. The clash between puppets and puppeteers is a primary element
of modern history. At the same time, it is best not to go from one extreme to
the other. When you push long and hard, once the opposition gives way there is
a powerful momentum to keep going far beyond the balance point. Here is where
an uncommon restraint is needed. Nitya touches on this in his assessment of the
need for security:
The instinct of self-preservation
exaggerates the sense of insecurity and prompts the need to find measures by
which one can have economic, social, moral and spiritual security. These
exaggerated needs of the mind push the person into various avenues of activity,
which should more aptly be called karma—actions prompted by desire—and desires
born of ignorance.
Life is generally uncertain, but we crave certainty.
Security is one of the projected values we might examine based on this verse.
Can I have enough faith in the beneficence of the universe to live with a fair
measure of insecurity? Security is a first-chakra issue; in other words it is a
primary need on which to build a healthy psyche. But if we exaggerate our sense
of insecurity we may never be secure. Surely if it is based on external
supports, security will always be something we can lose, so our anxiety will
not go away. Nitya cautions:
The negative aspect of the
instinct of preservation produces many forms of irrational fear. When such fear
is intensified, a person may even go insane. Even in normal persons there are
several hidden pathological tendencies, and even in “noble” sentiments, such as
love or devotion, the operating dynamic can be a pathological sense of
insecurity. This is a predominant factor in women when they grow old and lose
their bargaining powers of physical appearance and sexual charm. People who
make a living with their creative powers are also very apprehensive of old age.
In old age the external world becomes anemic or barren and devoid of values.
The apprehension about old age made up a significant chunk
of our class discussion. I’ll add some consoling ideas about it in Part II I
think you’ll find amusing.
my understanding, Nitya’s last sentence above is what Narayana Guru is
referring to with the mirage forest: “In old age the external world becomes
anemic or barren and devoid of values.” If we have not struck a close
relationship with our inner truth, when all of what we rely on in its place
fails us, we will be left destitute. Sensing this on the horizon should
energize us to turn to a firmer basis for our joy. Nitya puts it this way: “Inner
maturity that is not vitiated by pathological tendencies turns naturally from
the external world to a more abiding reality which is seen in the Self.”
mused how the old in our society are considered useless throwaways, and if we
anticipated them to be wise it would change our social expectations
dramatically. We didn’t address the stake that business and politics have in
keeping people isolated, and especially keeping them from factual knowledge,
but those are powerful forces working against the sane attitude Bill proposed,
where we are connected and aware, transcending all stratifications including
those by age. In short, it makes good economic sense to write off the wise as
ridiculous. Our society is masterful at doing it convincingly.
addition to those horizontal pressures toward despair, many successful
religious charlatans offer themselves or their programs as the stable basis for
faith, and apparently this satisfies legions of seekers. Narayana Guru is honest
in treating such attitudes as more illusory projections. In Nitya’s words, they
are examples of rati: projected value-visions that we eagerly interact with.
The value people assign them, whatever they may be, is what makes them
adorable. As long as you know you are projecting and it could fall apart at any
time, you can go ahead. But beware! Many have been sucked in far beyond what
we know and Deb reminded us, the solution is to discover ourselves as the
source of happiness and awareness. When we are grounded in Self-realization,
everything we encounter is affected by our glow. The open secret is that beauty
is not intrinsic to the object; we connect with it in ourselves. Jan talked
about how much she loves beauty and is always looking for ways to further that
experience. She feels she has a growing capacity to see beauty everywhere, and
it is very exciting to her. Additionally, she has achieved a new level of
independence in her life, so she doesn’t have so much pressure to keep going toward
some factual goal to accommodate others. She can take time out to appreciate
the glorious environments she moves through, whenever she wants.
agreed that ideas, programs and plans are just our private fantasies in a way.
Narayana Guru is suggesting that here is where our understanding is off the
mark. We tune out the world’s magnificence when we substitute our petty
talked about an article he read recently in Tricycle magazine about taking the
time to see and enjoy the world’s beauty. We have to decide to set aside our
ongoing agenda to really look at things. In a way we have to aspire to
alertness. Moni agreed you have to slow down before you can begin to move to an
inner focus. Deb sagely described it as seeing in context. She gently disagreed
with the simplistic way it is often taken, that we tune out the world to access
our inner reality. Turning inward does not meaning turning away from anything.
Again, this is a yogic secret that we will be making much of in the later
darsanas of our study.
recalled how Nitya would often pause during walks to admire something
beautiful, to remind those with him to stop and smell the flowers. He well knew
the joy he felt was his own contribution. He would sometimes say, looking at a
rose or a sunset, “Aren’t I beautiful?” The object was eliciting his innate
joy, and his joy was in turn illuminating the object as worthwhile. Reciprocity
is the key. Both halves belong together.
gave one of many possible examples of projected value-visions that throw our
lives into turmoil, in hopes that some of us will take the gurus’ invitation to
see through their illusory nature. As a young man I was caught up in the spirit
of the 1960s, full of passionate antiwar and pro civil rights outbursts. In
those days our enemy was labeled either the Establishment or simply the
Country. We railed against the hypothetical concept of the Country, not
realizing it was a vague compilation of a vast number of concepts ranging from
true to false. In other words, it was a fiction. Had to be. On account of this
our efforts were often in vain: like Don Quixote we were tilting at windmills,
and the windmills just kept blowing in the wind. With the passage of time I can
see that the concept of Country has steadily changed throughout my life. When
was it ever real? Never. It was a fiction we used as a kind of shorthand for
our beliefs. We were exploding with misdirected energies, in most cases causing
more damage than we repaired.
often noted that ‘husband’, ‘wife’, and so on were similar fictions that cause
us no end of confusion. Maya is a favorite cliché of Indian philosophers, a
term to excuse the inability to grasp any subject. “It’s just maya.” Case
closed. We will have to work hard to avoid that pitfall in the next darsana,
the Maya Darsana. All this projecting is “ignorance,” which is yet another
vague concept deflecting us from meaningful contemplation.
suggestion that what we needed was humility—to be humble about our selves—was
spot on. We have to accept that the mask of our persona, of being in charge,
will have to be lost. It’s okay.
hard to believe that there is still more material in this brief verse
commentary, but at the end Nitya offers a consoling yogic perspective that Jan
brought to our attention:
The principle drive of life,
known as rati (the capacity to
interact with objects of pleasure and projected value-visions) disappears, and
in its place arati comes. Arati is total indifference to all kinds
of aids, physical or mental. At this stage a person can easily become
indifferent and withdrawn; arati
leads to death. But if the mature person is wise, there arises a natural
consciousness out of the subjective promptings to seek happiness and situations
that bring fulfillment out of dissatisfaction. Duality fades out, the blissful
nature of the Self slowly or suddenly becomes unveiled, and wisdom prevails.
The revealed reality of the Self is the only factor that remains thereafter
unassailed by the ravages of changing forms. Out of the ever-changing flux the
beingness of pure duration emerges.
Jan astutely realized that arati is not the correction for
rati, it is the dialectical opposite, and they are to be canceled out in a
neutral wisdom that includes both together while transcending their impact.
Where rati leads to immersion in life at the expense of our freedom, arati
leads to death through abandonment. Somehow we have to access a third option,
which adds a whole other layer to life beyond the ordinary dichotomy, one that
can only be revealed by yogic contemplation. In Jan’s estimation this is what
leads to ripeness in old age. She also felt it was well worth asking yourself
what are the key ingredients of the rest of my life? Hopefully they would
include a stable grounding in self-awareness, so that when the less permanent
ingredients fade out, as they must, the happiness of the Self would not go with
people look upon this world like a sky-forest imagined in the Self. In other
words, they see everything in the form of the Self and they treat the world as
unreal, because it is supposed in the Self. They understand that the Self alone
is real. It is only unwise people who think the world is real. Children who
lack understanding treat lifeless and inert puppets as equally real as
themselves and play with them carrying on a conversation. Only those of maturer
years know that such things are inert and lifeless.
of our dear departed friends here in Portland is Terry O’Donnell, a celebrated
author who lived in Iran for some 20 years. Iran has a culture that respects
old age, something that we can hardly imagine ever returning to our part of the
world. Isn’t this a charming vignette?
O’Donnell’s servant Mamdali, a spectacular character out of
the old-fashioned Iranian peasantry, has just related an absurd story to him,
vouching for it by the fact that it was told to him by a very old man:
He must have noted the
incredulous look on my face, for he repeated that the man who had told the story
had been very old. It reminded me of the evening when he was lighting the fire
with an old copy of Time magazine and
I happened to explain to him Time’s
practice of choosing the most important man of the year for its New Year cover.
“Oh, I see,” he said. “You mean the oldest man in your country.” And there came
on his face that smile, musing and tender, which always appeared when to him
the world seemed right. (23)
Terence O’Donnell, Garden
of the Brave in War: Recollections of Iran (Chicago: University of Chicago
the old article on wisdom and aging that I’ve shared before, which should help
you frame your fate in a more positive way. The original may be found here: http://www.nytimes.com/2008/05/20/health/research/20brai.html?_r=0
Older Brain Really
May Be a Wiser Brain
By SARA REISTAD-LONG
Published: May 20, 2008
When older people can no longer remember names at a cocktail
party, they tend to think that their brainpower is declining. But a growing
number of studies suggest that this assumption is often wrong.
Instead, the research finds, the aging brain is simply
taking in more data and trying to sift through a clutter of information, often
to its long-term benefit.
The studies are analyzed in a new edition of a neurology
book, “Progress in Brain Research.”
Some brains do deteriorate with age.
Alzheimer’s disease, for example, strikes 13 percent of Americans 65 and
older. But for most aging adults, the authors say, much of what occurs is a
gradually widening focus of attention that makes it more difficult to latch
onto just one fact, like a name or a telephone number. Although that can be
frustrating, it is often useful.
“It may be that distractibility is not, in fact, a bad
thing,” said Shelley H. Carson, a psychology
researcher at Harvard whose work was cited in
the book. “It may increase the amount of information available to the conscious
For example, in studies where subjects are asked to read
passages that are interrupted with unexpected words or phrases, adults 60 and
older work much more slowly than college students. Although the students plow
through the texts at a consistent speed regardless of what the out-of-place
words mean, older people slow down even more when the words are related to the
topic at hand. That indicates that they are not just stumbling over the extra
information, but are taking it in and processing it.
When both groups were later asked questions for which the
out-of-place words might be answers, the older adults responded much better
than the students.
“For the young people, it’s as if the distraction never
happened,” said an author of the review, Lynn Hasher, a professor of psychology
at the University of Toronto and a senior scientist at the Rotman Research
Institute. “But for older adults, because they’ve retained all this extra data,
they’re now suddenly the better problem solvers. They can transfer the
information they’ve soaked up from one situation to another.”
Such tendencies can yield big advantages in the real world,
where it is not always clear what information is important, or will become
important. A seemingly irrelevant point or suggestion in a memo can take on new
meaning if the original plan changes. Or extra details that stole your
attention, like others’ yawning and fidgeting, may help you assess the
speaker’s real impact.
“A broad attention span may
enable older adults to ultimately know more about a situation and the indirect
message of what’s going on than their younger peers,” Dr. Hasher said. “We
believe that this characteristic may play a significant role in why we think of
older people as wiser.”
In a 2003 study at Harvard, Dr. Carson and other researchers
tested students’ ability to tune out irrelevant information when exposed to a
barrage of stimuli. The more creative the students were thought to be,
determined by a questionnaire on past achievements, the more trouble they had
ignoring the unwanted data. A reduced ability to filter and set priorities, the
scientists concluded, could contribute to original thinking.
This phenomenon, Dr. Carson said, is often linked to a
decreased activity in the prefrontal cortex. Studies have found that people who
suffered an injury or disease that lowered activity in that region became more
interested in creative pursuits.
Jacqui Smith, a professor of psychology and research
professor at the Institute for Social Research at the
University of Michigan, who was not involved in the current research,
said there was a word for what results when the mind is able to assimilate data
and put it in its proper place — wisdom.
“These findings are all very consistent with the context
we’re building for what wisdom is,” she said. “If older people are taking in
more information from a situation, and they’re then able to combine it with
their comparatively greater store of general knowledge, they’re going to have a