Bhakti Darsana verse 8
Thus the wise man sees everywhere
nothing but the joy of the Self –
not even a little of anything else.
indeed is the highest.
Nataraja Guru’s translation:
the wise man who sees
at any place whatever
is nothing at all other than Self-Bliss;
verily is the highest.
Guru simplifies the essence of wisdom to its minimum requirements here: the
best contemplative sees nothing but the Self, everywhere. There isn’t much you could
add to that, so Nitya once again sketches the ways we deviate from such an
awareness. His job was to remind us to get back to the essence, over and over,
until it happened to happen. His task never ended, as simplicity remains
verse says that the highest form of bhakti is when you see only joy everywhere.
The reaction of the typical human to this is, “But… but… but….” It’s so hard to
accept, because it isn’t merely a belief, it has to be a realization. With our
habitual divisive thinking we just don’t get it. We are attuned to perceive
areas of possible joy and vast stretches of joylessness, particularly in
chaotic times such as the one we find ourselves in now, and aim for the one and
reject the other.
the hope we will learn a yogic orientation to supplant our inherited
transactional expertise of separating everything, Nitya runs us through the
basic picture again and again. The first order of business is to match our
conceptions with our perceptions. Again, that sounds simple enough, yet the
human mind has a fantasizing tendency that overlays wishful thinking and
bizarre beliefs onto the ground of what we perceive, and the outcome is almost
certainly conflict. Nitya says:
When the alignment between
perceived objects and their conceived properties is erroneous, perceptual
illusions take the place of objective observations. When the required alignment
has a correct one-to-one correspondence, the ensemble reckoned by the mind as
the ‘other’ provides for a valid transactional context for the individuated
self to enter into encounters or reactions.
So the first task of the spiritual aspirant is to become
aware of and then subtract the projections and superimpositions we routinely
add on top of the ocean of joy in which we are eternally swimming. This
wouldn’t be too hard if there were gurus everywhere reminding us, but instead
we are surrounded by charlatans actively promoting their own selfish interests
at the expense of anyone who will buy into their manipulative sales pitches.
Which is why Nitya observes that “In the case of most people, consciousness is
more or less filled with the fluctuating details of the illusory and the
seem to be living in a time of the explosion of lunatic beliefs about God that
are having real impacts on people’s lives, abd the Self is a most fertile
ground for misaligned correspondences between ideas and reality. It’s no joke
that well-armed cruelty and viciousness are widely extolled, even within
several major religions. The most salient place to misalign our ideas about the
Self with a pure, neutral version is religion. The Self is most often called by
some name of God. Everyone agrees that God is all-loving, all-wise,
all-compassionate, and so on, yet all sorts of opposite concepts are glorified
alongside of these estimable qualities. Here in the US we see our President,
Trump, extolled as the perfect Christian. Never mind that he is the exact
opposite of everything the Biblical Christ stood for and bears no relation
whatsoever to him, because if you believe it, it must be true. Your friends in
your chosen echo-chamber agree with you, making it even more true. A huge
billboard has sprung up on the road to the Portland Gurukula, part of a massive
read-the-Bible campaign, claiming improbably “Read the Bible to find out why
Jesus created you.” Nowhere in the Bible does it claim Jesus created anyone.
Maybe that’s the idea: people will pore through the whole Bible looking for
that claim, and though they never find it they will have read the whole book.
Anyway, it would be farcical if the same people weren’t advocating guns for
all, I suppose also in the name of Jesus, the Prince of Peace. War is Peace,
Freedom is Slavery, Ignorance is Strength. These are glaring examples of what
Nitya means when he talks of a “fake norm of ananda.” False values, cherished
because you hope they will serve you according to some perverse fantasy. Sadly,
as several of us know perfectly well from personal experience, false hope in
false values is truly self-destructive.
seekers are dedicated to relieving themselves of burdensome beliefs, especially
about the most far-reaching aspects of life, like God. It’s ultimately for
their own good. As Bushra beautifully put it, if you are accusing you are
adding to the violence. She gave the example of Saddam Hussein in her native
Iraq, who was accused of every terrible thing, some true, some not. Yet under
his rule Iraq thrived, and when he was deposed things got much worse. It’s an
old story. We accuse because we imagine it lets us off the hook. As studies
have shown, blaming is contagious. And it isn’t effective in any real way.
Bushra’s example reminded me of Nataraja Guru’s joke about standing in a noisy
room and yelling at the top of your voice for silence. You only make it louder
wondered whether the terrible things that happen don’t sow the seeds for great
things in their aftermath. If everything is connected and in balance, maybe
that’s how evolution goes forward. Pain can help us have a clearer perspective.
idea of perspective reminded Karen of a poster she’s seen of a wide swath of
the universe, galaxy upon galaxy forever, with an arrow pointing to a tiny
speck in a recondite corner, indicating “You are here.” Bill summarized the turmoil
as nothing more than elements of the world playing out. Yet it’s very hard for
us to maintain a logically detached state of mind. Only if we can see
everything as the Self does it become somewhat easier.
visitor Charles imagined a far-off country ruled by Republicans and Democrats,
one good the other bad, and was puzzled how to fit Narayana Guru’s philosophy
into such a scene, in case he should find himself in a place like that. Deb
remembered that Nitya advised always going to the heart of a person, as the
heart was the true source of the social person. That means he was always trying
to find out the cause of each person’s attitude, instead of dealing with only
said this was where the simple version of this verse is all you need to know:
if you are taking sides, you aren’t living up to the highest contemplative
ideal. Any way at all that you rate one thing over another, you are addressing
something other than the oceanic joy of the Self. It’s a challenge because when
we look at the surface we see terrible things happening, and we want to replace
them with good things. The class unfurled a long and fruitful discussion about
looking to the cause instead of being captivated by the effect. I wish you were
there, because I’m not going to write about it.
one example, though, I’m reading Out of
the Wreckage, by George Monbiot, an examination of the beliefs that have
brought us to national and international disaster, and how that might be
rectified. The core beliefs of Republicans and Democrats are largely the same.
One is more heartless than the other, but when those are the core beliefs,
disaster is assured whether you’re nasty or nice. It has already happened many
times over, so it isn’t speculative. The point is that choosing between one
version or the other of a failed philosophy is not going to get you anywhere.
You will only be effective if you find out what the underlying motivations are
and address those. The same is true of our psyches, of course.
paraphrased Suzuki Roshi: as the world is permeated with evil, if you want to
see the Absolute you have to become quiet. I was reminded how ineffective I am
when caught up in noise and turmoil—my only hope of being in any way valuable
to a situation is to find a quiet retreat and gather myself together. When I
do, I often have useful insights, and may even be able to act on them.
of the beliefs that keeps us bound to illusions is that we don’t have to do
anything to undo our bondage. Since so many of our efforts are futile or
misdirected, we come to believe that all efforts beyond obvious transactional
exchanges are futile, which is extremely unhelpful. The rishis offer a more
propitious narrative that can lead us out of the ocean of samsara and back into
the ocean of joy from which we have sprung. It goes like this:
The cognitive mind has a tendency
to move from multifarious effects to a unitive cause, so that the many can be
unified through a process of reduction to arrive at a basic factor in which are
seeded all the ramifications of consequential developments. When this tendency
is promoted, the philosopher’s quest to apprehend the source of everything
increases until it culminates in an intuitive vision which becomes more and
more organized, holistic, and reliable as a constant ground which has the
potential to manifest itself into the variegated world of names and forms.
This doesn’t mean we should abandon our common sense
respecting the world we live in, it only means that if we lose touch with our
inner strength we will find ourselves at the mercy of a constantly shifting and
deceptive milieu, a nightmare where we are driven by the walls of our cage:
In the perceptual appreciation,
the operative force that acts as a mechanism of attraction or repulsion is an
instinctive conditioning of a vitalistic order, which is inherited by all
living beings to a certain extent as a device for the organism’s
self-preservation. This instinct misfires when the previously mentioned
alignment between the perception and its corresponding conception is
erroneously made. Then it is not very different from the trial and error chance
operation one sees in the case of the rat in the maze.
There’s a hint here that a healthily holistic attitude has
an actual impact on the world of names and forms, so it’s more than
our own salvation is by no means a trivial endeavor of a dilettante, as it is
likely to be viewed by traumatized maze-walkers. It requires both courage and
the good fortune to have enough freedom to experiment with various options. We
are rapidly coming to the end of a historical period where large numbers of
people had quite a bit of freedom to experiment, and those who didn’t may rue
the time wasted once they have no more to throw away.
not talking here about being the smartest person in the room, which is a
The growth from mechanistic
gestaltation to a more intelligent appreciation of a consciously apprehended
ensemble shows maturity. Yet even this ability brings a person only to a level
of the mediocre assessment of subject-object relationships.
Nitya is speaking of the arena of competitive games that
absorbs most of our attention. Behind it is the idea that wealth, fame and
success bring joy automatically. It is certainly an appealing notion, no matter
how many stories we hear of the emptiness that isn’t purged by opulence or
popularity. But if we are brave enough to see through this illusion, we may
naturally turn to a more yogic type of mentality where inner and outer factors
are brought together harmoniously:
It is in this rapid current of
mind that the subtle maneuvering of consciousness enters to give the whole
experience a meaning and worthwhileness of a perennial nature.
The class took this to mean the emergence from duality into
unity, from taking sides to seeing the joy of the eternal in everything,
without exception. There are always plenty of disheartening actions happening
that threaten to steal away our joy, and they will if our joy is based on
certain defined limits. The joy of being on the right side, the winning team,
of being holier than thou, and so on, do not meet Narayana Guru’s definition of
the highest type of contemplative bliss. The surface will always have two
sides. That’s why we have to contemplate a total unity as an Absolute without
attributes. The minute we give it a nuance or a twist, even the very best twist
we can imagine, it becomes limited, and falsehood quickly colors our
impression. Suddenly there are some catching the boat and some missing it.
That’s not where we’re going with this! And yet we fall back into that kind of
thinking all the time.
should probably take a moment to clarify Nitya’s paragraph presenting the
complex enigmas that keep our head spinning:
The three orders of the mosaic
that go into the structuring of the world, the two streams that culminate in
the confluence of the unified stream, and the three appraisals of the
imperiential connotation such as the meaning, the self, and the Absolute, are
all in a muddle until wisdom prevails to sort them out and relate with
diligence the triads of the physical, psychological, and cosmologic aspects of
the entire situation. All these aspects are replete with enigmas of the worst
The three orders are the perceptual, the conceptual and the
intuitive, in other words, what we perceive, how we think of it, and what our
instincts tell us about it. These last range from raw gut reactions to the
sublime wisdom of our inner genius, and it’s the role of the conceptual mind to
sort those out and apply them to the other two. The two streams are the same
system without the conscious conceptual, leaving only the perceptual and the
intuitive. If these can be brought into confluence it produces an “incessant
flow” of a “rapid current of mind.” The three appraisals listed are essentially
ananda, chit and sat, in that order.
is not so simple to keep these complex factors regulated in an effective way.
Nitya reminds us that “What
should be the most tangible, objective, and irrefutably existent can also be
the most spurious phantom of an illusion.” He goes on:
In most cases such defects belong to a
possibility of error shared by all members of the species and the detection of
the error comes to most people only when it is too late to rectify.
Nitya used to say that the generic possibility of error was
what Christians meant by original sin: the limitations of the innate structure
of our being. We are built in a certain fashion, and this precludes any number
of other things from being natural to how we function. You could also call it
maya. The Christian notion of
individual sin covers the region we actually have control over, the
mistakes we make due to our own poor choices.
again sat, chit and ananda are threaded through the entire presentation. Nitya
takes a close look at the middle term of saccidananda:
The second realm… is the individuated
which can function merely as the mind propelled by desires and sustained by
memories, representing a faulty ego, or it can assume the mighty role of
transmuting everything into modes of consciousness as the supreme and primal cit. This is the golden link between
existence and value, which can rightly be called the subsistent. It dominates
the limitless world of consciousness, which includes in it both the conscious
and the unconscious, and the known and the unknown.
Existence and value are of course sat and ananda. The
Gurukula excels in treating ananda as much more than bliss, which is the
ordinary translation. The bliss of ananda arises from value assessment, which
provides meaning. The meaning of a thing is what gives it its impact. Nitya
adds evaluation to the definition of ananda, highlighting the personal
involvement. The three aspects of saccidananda are of course one universal
thing described with three aspects. Nitya portrays this vividly as the
variously perceived, conceived and evaluated, reflecting Narayana Guru’s use of
brahma, atma and ananda throughout this chapter, as an alternative form of
The true bhakta is one who is established in the consubstantiality
eternal trios, who is capable of unflinchingly holding on to the one
existentiality of the differently perceived, the differently conceived, and the
differently evaluated ground of all.
the ground does not change because we happen to be seeing or describing it in
various ways. The minute we forget we are only imagining the change, we set up
a division and prepare to do battle over it. So we are called to continually
purify our thinking by paring it down to a non-differentiated basis, almost
like a mathematical point or an empty void. And sorry folks, this doesn’t
happen without effort:
Effecting this most needed purification
vast realm of consciousness is the critical challenge which every seeker of the
Self has to take upon themselves. All the disciplines enjoined in the wisdom
texts of religions, all the austerities of mystics, and the self-discipline
practiced by yogis are most useful to convert this infinite realm from the
ocean of misery to the ocean of knowledge.
enough to have a simplistic belief that everything is one, we have to reduce
everything that catches us out, back to a level where it is connected. Doing so
is our contribution to peace and harmony. Anything less falls short of Narayana
Guru’s ideal, which we revere as the way to promote the kind of world we all
aspire to live in and enjoy.
it might happen by accident, but it’s highly unlikely.
shared a sweet story illustrative of how to have a unitive attitude when
confronting terrible circumstances. Thich Nhat Hanh was asked by a distraught
soldier what he should do to atone for killing a child in the war. Hanh told
him there a millions of children who need help right now. Help one of them and
you will be healed.
so perfect! We waste our lives stewing over our mistakes, when we could truly
atone for them by a generosity of spirit. Not just in our mind, but in the most
actual ways possible.
noted that Nitya was keen on tangents in his commentary, maintaining that
through wisdom you regain the holistic world. Writing about joy is problematic,
but much can be said about the impediments to happiness. Like the Absolute, to
describe joy is to shrink it, so we leave that to direct experience. But
Michael did us the honor of relating a joyful moment at work, and it made us
all feel even better. He was talking on the phone with a customer, a woman who
is on death’s door, and so lives every moment to the hilt. Her voice alone was full
of joy, and he was thrilled. Every moment of her life, no matter how mundane,
was blissful, she said, because she was alive to be there with it. She is
living every day to the maximum of her ability. It made Michael want to rush
home and put a note on his fridge: Find Joy!
the same spirit, Deb related her time at this weekend’s piano concert,
performed by identical twins, Christina and Michelle Naughton. To her they were
like angels, expressing and sharing abundant joy in the world. They emanated a
palpable bliss as they played, and their technical ability was almost
unbelievable. We talked briefly with them afterwards, and they struck us as a
force of nature, wired in ecstasy and barely noticing the shadowy humans in
front of them. They bowled everyone over.
Nancy’s theory of balance is right—and I’m sure it is—then we will see more of
these natural yogis, highly evolved beings, as the dark netherworld of the
human psyche shrieks into disaster. It’s a philosophical delicatessen out
mused on how the figure eight of consciousness image touched on “the
transcendent imminence and the imminent transcendence.” Transcendence is a
feature of the vertical axis—call it the goal of moving from the alpha to the
omega. Immanence is the horizontal component at every step of the progression.
We treat them as separate for convenience, but they are always one, so we
should apprehend them from a position of
“neutral zero,” as Nitya liked to put it. This is symbolized as the
point of intersection of the two zeroes that form the 8. Paul is right that
there is a movement implied. We contemplate the transcendent and then bring
what we learn into immanence, into every aspect of our environment. Or we
contemplate our world, and then look for how all those manifold items have a
transcendental, unitive basis embracing them. We are not going to insist on one
or the other standing alone. They depend on each other.
we have to be mentally flexible to shift our position to accurately see what’s
going on in the depths. The present political turmoil is just another example
of what happens when you live in a fantasy world and ignore important problems
until they become intractable, when they have you by the throat. Narayana Guru
invites us to get on with it now:
Only these truest of all
contemplatives can lucidly shift their position from one angle of vision to
another so that they can have an unprejudicial appreciation of every
individuated being’s value-orientation and concealed or expressed motivation.
As they see clearly the triple manifestation of the illusory, the
transactional, and the transcendental, they excel in maintaining their position
in the neutral zero from where they can easily enter into the transcendent
imminence and the imminent transcendence of the most adorable Absolute. It is
this efficiency that makes their contemplation the highest of all achievements.
We have been celebrating the birth of Bill and Nancy’s first
grandchild, who Deb and I had met yesterday, on her fifth day out in the light.
It reminds you how a baby is drenched in the Self, and as I held her I
whispered to her, “remember this place.” Of course, she won’t, consciously.
None of us do. But we know it instantly if we are fortunate enough to find our
way back. Deb and I were both reminded of a favorite saying of Tagore: “Every
child comes with the message that God is not yet discouraged of man.”
In the same way as worldly people enjoy sensual pleasures on
the basis of the Bliss of the Self, so too the wise man enjoys Self-Bliss
everywhere. He does not see anything but Self-Bliss in any object of interest.
Because a wise man knows the unity of the living Self and the Supreme Self, the
bliss he enjoys everywhere is known by him to belong to the Self. What is more,
he treats without any difference all such bliss anywhere and in any creature as
belonging to himself. In other words, the bliss of the creature is identical
with the Bliss of the Self. The wise man understands this verity. Because he is
capable of seeing all bliss as pertaining to the Absolute, his contemplation is
called the most exalted.
sent a link to a discussion you may find helpful and amusing:
This lengthy anthology (?) of several articles on the topic
speaks wisely to things we were discussing in class last evening.
I highly recommend it.